Wakulat|Law Supports Friends of Wind's Public Outreach

Introduction
Ever since the Province of Ontario introduced its landmark Green Energy and Green Economy Act, two major tracks of criticism have bedevilled the wind sector. First, developers are more likely to find local communities opposing proposed wind farms that have taken advantage of the streamlined approval process implemented by the Act. This lack of required consultation has created a sense of helplessness as rural residents feel large numbers of turbines are erected without regard to their visual or health concerns. This has stirred an emotionally divisive debate across the province's countryside that has proven grist for the government's political opponents in an election year.

The Impact on Health
While beauty is in the eye of the beholder, it should be an easier task to address health concerns with facts and research.  Earlier this year, Toronto-based environmental lawyer Dianne Saxe reported on a full-day webcast - Wind Power & Human Health Scientific Forum - dedicated to discussing wind power effects on human health.  The conclusion was essentially that "infrasound from wind turbines is not a health problem." This accords with an earlier report from Dr. Arlene King, Ontario's Chief Medical Officer of Health, who concluded that there is "no direct causal link between wind turbines and adverse health effects." Naturally, health professionals and wind proponents should take any concerns raised by residents seriously, but reasoned debate should be expected from all sides and include an understanding of the established facts to date.

Friends of Wind
Earlier this month Wakulat|Law had the privilege of participating in a public forum organized by a nascent grassroots group: "Friends of Wind". The group's research has indicated that "public opinion polls have consistently shown the majority of Canadians support wind energy for its environmental, economic and social benefits". They became concerned that this point-of-view was being lost to the more vocal groups bringing wind development into disrepute. Led by a full-time farmer and mother of four, Jutta Splettstoesser, Friends of Wind decided to put on four public events where industry experts could share the facts with interested residents, citizens and policymakers.

Jutta has been supported in her efforts by like-minded individuals and wind energy industry leaders keen to ensure all citizens can “join the conversation” about Ontario's energy future. Their fourth and final event was held on September 8, 2011 in London, Ontario. Wakulat|Law Principal Robert Wakulat moderated a panel that included the following expert speakers:

• Gideon Forman, Executive Director, Canadian Association of Physicians for the Environment
• Paul Seccaspina, CEO of Oraclepoll Research Limited
• Horia Hangan, Director of University of Western Ontario Wind Tunnel & Project Lead WindEEE
• Vinay Sharma, CEO, London Hydro

Forman, as he has done in the past, tackled the health issue and asked attendees to consider the health impacts of alternative generation options such as nuclear and coal. Seccaspina provided detailed insights into the minds of Ontarians with a focus on their attitudes towards renewable power and the upcoming provincial election:

Friends of Wind_Sept7

The Changing Landscape of Ontario

I recently had the pleasure of traveling across parts of beautiful southwestern Ontario on a couple of road trips. With the cooperation of some incredible early summer weather, I began to finally see the impact of the province's push to build a distributed and green energy grid. While there is still a ways to go before this area is mistaken for the German countryside, there has clearly been a shift in the level of interest in renewable energy generation.

My first excursion was a round-tripper from Toronto to Port Elgin via Orangeville.  The Canadian Autoworkers union was hosting a retreat for the bi-annual environment conference of its Health and Safety Department. The conference, held at the incredible CAW family education centre on the shores of Lake Huron, was attended by workers represented by CAW locals. You can learn more about their environment programme, by reviewing their statement of principles  and checking out their website. 

This leg of the trip exposed me to a number of wind and solar PV installations, increasing in frequency the closer I was to Port Elgin. There were smaller wind farms along the way culminating in a large collection just south of town. The solar installations alternated between ground-mounted dual-axis tracking installations, fixed ground-mounts and much larger custom-built barns to support large micro-FIT rooftop solar.

My next excursion was a lively affair with the ZooShare Biogas Cooperative team to learn about anaerobic digestion in the Niagara region. Vandermeer Greenhouses began in 1976 after Peter Vandermeer had sold his share of a greenhouse business in Holland and emigrated to Canada with his wife and daughter. Two years later, he purchased 5 acres in Niagara-on-the-Lake and started building. Operations slowly expanded over the years eventually reaching 280,000 square feet and becoming the largest grower of cut mums in Ontario.

Primary and secondary digesters w greenhouse in background.

In addition to becoming a greenhouse leader, the Vandermeers were attuned to other ways they could improve their operations. This led them to research and develop an anaerobic digestion installation. It consists of primary and secondary digesters that are 18 m in diameter and 6 m high; a digestate storage container; an engine producing 335 kW of electricity fed into the provincial grid and 402 kW of thermal heat used in the greenhouse.

The digesters are fed grape pumice from local vintners, expired dog food from a dog food supplier in Guelph, Ontario, rotting or otherwise deficient produce from local farmers and coffee grind from a nearby Tim Hortons. In return, Vandermeer produces electricity and heat and digestate that can be used as an organic fertilizer for local farmers or the greenhouse.


However, proponents of green energy should not assume that this transformation is deep rooted. There are still a number of concerns and issues that must be addressed to assuage a variety of groups (including possibly the next government of the province) before the Green Energy and Green Economy Act will grow as sturdy as a mature oak tree.  Evidence of this discontent was also visible during my travels.

Hopefully, Ontarians will arrive at a solution to the development of green energy that will allow for interested developers and generators to reap the rewards for taking on significant risks but will also allow for the civil resolution of concerns expressed by neighbours and communities. Ontario has an opportunity to lead the way in North America and many residents have already opened the door to that opportunity.